Showing posts with label Millie Marries a Marshal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Millie Marries a Marshal. Show all posts

January 19, 2022

#TBRChallenge 2022: Millie Marries a Marshal


The Particulars: Historical western romance, Novella, 2014, In print, Available in digital, Book 2 in series.

Why Was It In Wendy's TBR?: I love historical westerns and I picked up a print copy of this at the only RT Book Reviews convention I attended.  Also, at some point this must have been a freebie because I also had an eBook copy languishing on my Kindle.

The Review: This is not a good book. Oh sure, there's a kernel of a good story here but everything about the execution is terrible. How do these people fall in love? Why do they fall in love?  Who the heck knows!  Because the author is much more concerned with burying her 120 page romance novella under a mountain of series-itis set-up and secondary characters instead of, oh I don't know, spending time developing her two main characters and the romance I'm supposed to care about.

Millie Donovan travels to Clear Creek, Kansas to become Sam Larson's mail-order bride.  Born and raised in Chicago, she had to hastily leave her pit-stop in St. Louis with her toddler "son," Tate, in tow.  Now she's on the railroad platform and has already, to her horror, attracted the notice of the town marshal.  Then he tells her Sam is dead and she, promptly, faints. As you do.

Adam Wilerson has vowed to stay a bachelor, mostly because of his job.  He and his brother had no idea their neighbor Sam was hooking up with a mail-order bride, but they discovered her letters when they were cleaning out his place after his death.  He deposits the too-thin woman and her son at the hotel and heads off to the family dinner he's already late for, only to get a severe dressing down from his mother and sister.  What do you mean you just dumped the shocking news on this poor woman and left her at the hotel?  A hotel that very likely doesn't have any rooms available because the town is bursting at the seams with folks passing through thanks to a cattle drive.

Adam tracks down Millie (her and Tate just got kicked out of squatting in the livery and trash-can diving for food) and Adam's mother steps in and decides that her bachelor son needs a housekeeper.  In exchange for cooking and cleaning, Millie gets room and board until she decides what to do next.  Eventually what happens is that somehow these two fall in love after spending zero time together and Millie's secrets come home to roost.

Why don't Millie and Adam spend time together?  Well, because he's actively avoiding her and the author instead chooses to fill a 120-page novella full to brimming with secondary characters.  Millie spends more time with Adam's mother than Adam - and that woman is a saint. It would have been more believable for her to fall in love with Cate!  This series is 12 books long and the reader is introduced to characters that show up in book one and books three through seven!  THIS IS A NOVELLA AND IS ONLY 120 PAGES LONG! WHY DEAR LORD, WHY?!?!?!?!

Ahem, anywho - it's no wonder I didn't believe in the romance.  With all these secondary characters floating around, when exactly does the author have time to develop the romance between Adam and Millie?  The answer is, she doesn't.  Compounding this problem is that when these two do manage to spend a few sentences on page together they lack any sort of chemistry or tension.  This is a just-kisses romance, but just because there's no sex in it does not mean romances can't or shouldn't have tension.  You can believe the characters are attracted to each other without them doing the mattress mambo, but they also have to spend time together to develop that tension, that chemistry.  And these two don't.  Instead I'm reading about Hilda's sod house and Cora running a ranch and Adam's widowed mother Cate and his sister Sarah and his brother Jacob getting married to Raina (see book one) and yada yada yada.

It's a shame because I do think there's a story here - uh, somewhere.  Namely when Millie's past shows up in town and all her secrets come tumbling out. It's a compelling plot idea and could make a good story.  It just didn't here.  Oh well.  Moving on.  And on a brighter note, since I had two copies of this in my TBR I'm weeding out two books this month!  That has a certain amount of logic to it, right?

Final Grade = D-