Amazon discontinued the ability to create images using their SiteStripe feature and in their infinite wisdom broke all previously created images on 12/31/23. Many blogs used this feature, including this one. Expect my archives to be a hot mess of broken book cover images until I can slowly comb through 20 years of archives to make corrections.

Friday, June 25, 2010

She's Got Ambition Baby

When I first heard about Maid To Match by Deeanne Gist all the way back in December 2009, I knew I was going to have to read it. Inspirational or no, I've literally been waiting for this book my whole historical romance reading loving life. A romance between a lady's maid and footman? Seriously, how can I not read this? And while it didn't quite live up to the immense hype I managed to conjure in my wee lil' librarian brain, it was still a very solid read, and one of the more memorable historicals I've run up against this year.

At 18, Tillie Reese has learned she is in the running to become Mrs. Vanderbilt's new lady's maid. Currently head parlormaid, getting promoted to lady's maid would be a huge honkin' deal. Only the housekeeper is higher in rank among the female staff, and the lady's maid gets to bathe whenever she darn well pleases, gets to read books aloud to Mrs. Vanderbilt, gets to dress in the same incredible fashions, and she'll get to travel with the Vanderbilts! It's what she, and her mother, have been working towards the past 18 years and it's almost within Tillie's grasp. However there's another girl in the running for the position, so Tillie has her work cut out for her. She cannot afford any distractions or any slip-ups. And that's when Mack Danvers shows up.

Mack's twin bother Earl already works up the Biltmore estate for the Vanderbilts as a footman. With both of their parents now gone, the boys have had to split up their family - farming the younger boys out to neighbors in their mountain community and putting the youngest girl in the local orphanage. When he finds out that the supposedly fine, upstanding head of the orphanage is beating the girls, he's determined to get his sister out of there. But for that he needs money, a lot more than he's making in his current job, and Earl's playboy ways means he's no help whatsoever. Then, in an amazing turn of events, he's offered a job at the Biltmore as the new useful man. He's loathe to take it, but dang, the Vanderbilts pay very well. More money means he can reunite the family that much sooner.

Of course, this throws a wrench into Tillie's ambitions. Naturally Mrs. Vanderbilt doesn't want Mack to be a useful man forever. He's just as handsome as his twin brother, and just think? Identical twin footmen! She'll be the envy of...well...every lady capable of breath. But Mack has spent his whole life in the mountains. He tends to speak freely and readily use his fists when someone crosses him the wrong way. It's up to Tillie to mold him into a proper servant, and getting her head turned by him is not an option. Getting tangled up with the fellow servant would lead to immediate dismissal and her dreams would go up in smoke.

Mack is this great mix of Alpha and Beta hero. Certainly he's rough around the edges, and uses his fists, but it's always to protect those in need. Women and children mostly. Because while many men from the mountain aren't big on equal rights, his father raised the boys to respect women. Period. So when Mack sees injustice, he tends to hit first and ask questions later. He's also immediately smitten with Tillie, and desperate to catch her favor. He knows she's also attracted to him, but he can't understand why she's so determined to give up her entire youth, a chance to marry and have children of her own, to serve some rich lady.

Tillie takes immense pride in her work, and sees the chance at being the new lady's maid as her ticket to a better life. Yes, she'll have to give up marriage and children. And yes, she'll be thrown over for some new young thang once she reaches a certain age. But, lady's maids are paid very, very well. It's money that can be used to help out her parents and further her own philanthropic endeavors. Plus, Mrs. Vanderbilt does a lot of good in the community. As a lady's maid, she could be part of that. The problem is, the more time she spends with Mack, the more she begins to question her dream. Is being a lady's maid really what she wants?

The author delivers a wonderful sense of place, utilizing the immense backdrop of the Biltmore to set her story. She also manages to portray the most realistic depiction of servants I've ever read in a romance novel. Granted, that's probably not saying much, since the historical accuracy of "the staff" in historical romances has always been laughable, at best. She gets the feel of "below stairs" just right. The gossip. The hierarchy. The demands. All of it. And to top it off we get an author's note at the end, explaining...well...a lot (FYI - American servant class = different from British servant class).

Given that this is an inspirational, "God stuff" should be expected. It's actually light to non-existent for the first half of the story. It becomes more prevalent in the latter half, as Tillie wrestles with the notion of what she really wants out of her life. The romance here is solid, but I actually wished it had been developed a bit more thoroughly. The attraction between Mack and Tillie is quite obvious. What isn't so obvious is them "falling in love." I wanted a lot more "how and why" and instead it just sort of "happens."

I also was a wee bit taken aback by a dark moment that occurs in the latter portion of this story. Not that the first half was light and fluffy, but just that it had the definite feel of "upstairs/downstairs" with the drama of dealing with visiting, and demanding, house guests. Certainly I enjoy "gritty" moments in my romances, welcome them in fact, but there's a development during the climatic final chapters that literally made me sit up, take notice, and wonder "what the?!?!?!" Was it realistic? Sadly, yes. Was it shocking? Way yes. It certainly does the job of moving the story through the concluding chapters, but I can't help but feel like I was blindsided with a sledge-hammer. Now obviously, the story ends the way all historical romances should end (yes, happy ending), but that doesn't make that moment any less shocking, any less troubling, or, most importantly, any less upsetting.

I loved the backdrop of the Biltmore Estate and the North Carolina mountains. I loved the careful historical research detailing the lives of the servants. I loved that while the Vanderbilts played decent-sized supporting roles, that this story was really about those people who served them. It's a strong, solid historical romance. If you're an inspirational fan, you need to plan on reading this book. Like, now. And for those of you desperate for the kind of story that secular publishers of historical romance seem determined to never give us? I didn't think it was great, but that doesn't make it any less good.

Final Grade = B


SarahT said...

I have this book on my TBR shelf and I'm looking forward to reading it.

Your review makes me want to start it right now!

Marguerite Butler said...

This made me want this book immediately. I'm so there for some upstairs/downstairs!

Jo said...

I'm adding this book to my list!!

Victoria Janssen said...

Thanks for the review! I was curious about this one.

Lori said...

I remember seeing something about this one. Guess I didn't realize it was an inspirational. Love the idea of the maid and the footman!! Putting this on my list. Thanks, Wendy!

AnimeJune said...

I've read Gist before (thanks to her bee-yoo-tee-ful covers), and yes, the religious element is usually worked pretty subtly into the story.

I'm very glad she's used accurate servant research (particularly that about hierarchy belowstairs - no valet would be friends with a footman, pshaw!). My WIP has a footman hero, too, and the research was pretty eye-opening.

Phyl said...

I remember when you mentioned this before. I'm so glad you let us know it's out. I'm anxious to read it, too. Sounds fun.

nath said...

Very interesting premise!! It's true that there's not many books with servants as H/H!!

Wendy said...

I'm a bit of a ho for Author's Notes at the end of historical romances, so was happy to see Gist included them here. Particularly the differences between American and British servants, and the food chain in a large household staff like the one the Vanderbilts would have employed.

I also appreciated that she gave us an accurate depiction of life in late 19th century North Carolina. Large families! Mountain communities! And certainly the circumstances that the hero's family was in wouldn't have been all that uncommon (splitting up the siblings after the parents had passed - BIG age differences between oldest and youngest etc.) I also thought she did a wonderful job with the heroine's mother, and detailing her dreams for her daughter to have a "better life."

Just a good, solid read.

Marie-Thérèse said...

This sounds like a fascinating book and one that's going into my wish list immediately! I watched 'Upstairs, Downstairs' religiously (*groan*) as a pre-teen girl and still vividly remember how touched I was by the romances between Daisy and Edward and Mr. Hudson and Mrs. Bridges (and, of course, Rose, the lady's maid, and her brief and tragic romance).

It's funny-I'm a nearly life-long atheist but lately I find myself reading more and more "inspirational" historical romance, not because of the spiritual aspects but because these are virtually the only romances I can find that deal with periods outside the long 18th century and classes lower than the landed gentry. I know at least a couple of other very non-religious romance readers who feel the same way. Are mainstream secular publishers missing the boat here or are we just anomalies?

mslizalou said...

Need to see if my library has this one. Sounds like a good read.

Rosie said...

I read my first Deanne Gist book a couple of months ago. Enjoyed as a solid 'B' read. I'm surprised I haven't seen this one. I'm intrigued though!

Wendy said...

Rosie: It just came out this month, so that's probably why it slipped under your radar :)

Marie: My vote goes to secular publishers missing the boat - but I'm a bitter American-set historical romance reader.

Besides the interesting settings and "different" characters, I also think a lot of readers pick up inspirationals because they want a "clean" read. No wall-to-wall sexxoring or naughty words.

Marie-Thérèse said...

Wendy, I hear you on the bitterness over the dearth of American-set romances. I don't get why there are so few of these either (but then there are lots of things I don't get about mainstream romance publishing).

I also think you're right about some non-religious readers picking up inspirationals because they offer a break from the repetitive half-dozen sex scenes every historical novel seems required to have now. This is something the romance group over at Library Thing has talked a bit about. There's a significant set of romance readers who like sex and erotica just fine (and have no problem with salty language) but have grown really tired of seeing essentially the same sexual scenario with the same descriptors featured over and over again in a single novel. For at least some of us, books with less sex often seem like they have time for more story and more exploration of the non-physical aspects of the romance.