Friday, October 16, 2009

SuperWendy's Top 16

Best known for her book, Forever Amber, author Kathleen Winsor, who passed away in 2003, would have been 90 years old today. In honor of her work, her life, and her all-around awesome-ness, our dear sweet Maili thought it would be fun to honor her birthday with a list of our Top 16 Romances. I think this is a smashing idea, and many thanks to Jessica for promoting it on her blog. Quite a few of these I've blogged about before, but dang, I couldn't very well leave them off my list. So here it goes. In no particular order:

1. Breathless by Laura Lee Guhrke - American Historical, Early 20th Century, Stand Alone - My favorite romance novel ever. Small-town librarian who is ::gasp:: divorced (!) wants to shut down local brothel. Some of the brothel's best customers, powerful, politically connected men, ask hero to intervene. The hero just happens to be the attorney who represented the heroine's scumbag, asshole ex in the divorce proceedings, and who essentially "won" the case by dragging heroine's reputation through the mud. Yeah. She's less than happy to see him rolling back into town.

2. The Firebrand by Susan Wiggs - American Historical, 19th Century, Book 3 In Trilogy - Suffragette heroine rescues baby being dangled from hotel balcony during the Great Fire Of Chicago. Fast forward five years, and heroine discovers her daughter's father is alive, well, and a powerful man. I loved this one because of the strong, yet vulnerable heroine. Also, one of the all-time great romantic scenes, where the hero and heroine kiss for the first time. Dreamy sigh.

3. I Do, I Do, I Do by Maggie Osborne - American Historical, 19th Century, Western-ish, Stand Alone - Three very different women find out they've all be wooed, wed and swindled by the same con man. They can't stand the sight of each other, but track the asshole all the way to Alaska at the height of the Yukon Gold Rush. That's where they meet their very own heroes. But where's the con man? And are any of them actually married? It's hard for me to pick my favorite Osborne, but this was the first one I ever read, so it wins.

4. The Nightingale's Song by Kathleen Eschenburg - American Historical, 19th Century, Part Of Two Book Series - Irish immigrant heroine with plans to become a nun gets attached to a young girl at the orphanage where she works. Turns out the child is the hero's by-blow, who just found out of the girl's existence, and is still haunted by the Civil War. Great history, great emotional intensity, just fantastic. Eschenburg only wrote two books, and then dropped off the map. RT reported in 2004 that she had breast cancer, and she recovered. If anyone has news of her, I'd love to hear it. This book rocked my world.

5. Courting Miss Hattie by Pamela Morsi - American Historical, 19th Century, Part Of Loosely Connected Series - Spinster, not very attractive, heroine finds herself with a suitor thanks to her prime farm land. Her best friend, the hero, has worked her farm for years and, even though he's engaged to the prettiest, brain-dead girl in the county, finds himself jealous. Then they share what was supposed to be an "innocent" kiss and whoa doggie!

6. To Dream Again by Laura Lee Guhrke - English Historical, Victorian, Stand Alone - You want emotion? Look no further. After her husband's death, heroine has worked her fingers to the bone making their factory a marginal success. However, now the bank is calling in her loan because ::shock:: she's a woman! With no husband! Enter the hero, stage left, who knew the heroine's dead husband and wants to use the factory to build....children's toys?!?! The heroine is scared, not to mention sick and tired of men who dream big but lack the follow-through. She thinks the hero is cut from the same cloth as her ex, only to discover just how wrong she is.

7. Bad Moon Rising by Katherine Sutcliffe - Romantic Suspense, Contemporary, Stand Alone - This book rocked my world when it was first published. It also turned off some of the more "conservative" (yeah, let's go with that...) romance readers who were horrified by the premise. Heroine is a former prostitute who gets a phone call from a panicking friend (who is still hooking). A serial killer is stalking the working girls of New Orleans. The hero is a disgraced attorney who fell into a bottle (and off the deep end) when a serial killer murdered his family. Dark, gritty, and oh how I wish Sutcliffe was still writing. Last I heard she was happily retired. Obviously she did not get the memo that it's all about me. Damn her.

8. Gossamer by Rebecca Hagan Lee - American Historical, 19th Century, Stand Alone - Heroine comes to San Francisco to meet up with her brother. Turns out though that brother is dead thanks to a raging opium addiction he picked up in Chinatown. Heroine eventually lands on the widowed hero's doorstep and is hired as the nanny to his four daughters. All Chinese girls he adopted after they were abandoned. OK, so it's probably not terribly realistic, but for the record: I don't care. My niece, The Fairy Princess, is Chinese (and adopted) so I have a soft spot for this book. I e-mailed the author (many moons ago) after reading and loving this story - and at the time (if I'm recalling correctly), she said the book didn't sell that well, but it had generated (by far) the most "fan mail" for her. Go figure.

9. A Reason to Live by Maureen McKade - American Historical, Western, Book 1 In Trilogy - I've blogged about this book a ton already. Heroine was a nurse working the front lines during the Civil War and now suffers from post-traumatic stress. She thinks she's going crazy, so her final mission is to deliver the dying words of some of her patients to their families. Along the way she meets the hero, a man desperate for any news about his son, who joined the war effort despite his objections. An emotional gut-puncher of a story.

10. Dirty by Megan Hart - Erotic Romance, Part Of Loosely Connected Series - Some would argue this isn't a romance, but I beg to differ. A self-destructive heroine who wields sex like a weapon meets her match in the hero, a man determined to love her. Whether she wants him to or not....

11. Hearts by Stef Ann Holm - American Historical, early 20th Century, Book 4 In Series - Heroine is suspended from her teaching job after discussing human sexuality with her female students. She travels to Montana to visit a pregnant friend, and tired of being seen as an athletic freak of nature, is determined to be "feminine." She runs up against the hero, a former body builder who now runs his own gym. He's immediately intrigued. Most women fall all over his muscles, while this one? She acts as if she's immune to his "charms." Totally and utterly delightful.

12. The Long Way Home by Cheryl Reavis - Silhouette Special Edition, Contemporary, Part Of Series - Heroine's dreams of being a Vegas showgirl go bust, so she heads back to her tiny southern hometown to regain custody of her daughter, who she essentially dumped on her ex. While home, she finds out her best friend, a military man, is in the hospital with injuries he sustained in the line of duty. There she runs up against the hero, also in the military and also injured. He's ornery as hell and she's feisty as a wildcat. Sparks immediately fly. A complex heroine trying to redeem herself after some disastrous life choices. Category romance at it's finest.

13. The Bride Fair by Cheryl Reavis - Harlequin Historical, 19th Century, American Historical, Part Of Series - Reavis is one of the few authors whose contemporary stories work just as well for me as her historicals. This one takes place post-Civil War. The hero is the occupying commanding officer in the town where he was once held as a prisoner of war. He's staying in the home of the heroine, which has been commandeered by the troops. They were on different sides during the war, and the heroine is shouldering her fair share of burdens and resentment. And yet? They can't seem to stay away from each other.

14. Prairie Wife by Cheryl St. John - Historical Historical, 19th Century, Western, Stand Alone - Another one I've blogged about tons. A marriage in trouble story about a couple that runs a way station for the local stagecoach. After the death of their toddler son, the heroine shuts down and the hero falls into a bottle. Stuff happens that shows them they need to wake up and save their marriage.

15. Nate by Lori Handeland - American Historical, Western, Book 5 In Series - I loved all the Rock Creek Six books, but this was my favorite by Handeland. A preacher turned gunman, the former Confederate soldier hero has lost his family, his faith, and has been slowly drinking himself to death. The heroine has been drawn to him ever since he and his friends rolled into town, and she's determined to save him from himself.

16. Cash by Linda Devlin - American Historical, Western, Book 6 In Series - See above. This is book six in the Rock Creek Six series, and one of my favorites because I was half in love with the hero by the time his book rolled around. Part charmer, part reprobate gambler, and very deadly with a gun, trouble finds him in the form of the heroine, his first and only love, who hunts him down looking for help with her son. Or should I say....their son. Uh oh.

And that's it folks. Hope you enjoyed reading this list. I know I had fun digging through the Bat Cave Keeper Stash. Many thanks to Maili for the fun idea!

19 comments:

Kristie (J) said...

I've either read or have all the books you have listed. The ones I have but not read yet
Dirty
Nate
Cash
I'll have to read now!! Some of the ones you have listed, I read 'cause of you *g* 'specially The Nightengale's Song. I think the only one I don't own or haven't read is The Long Way Home.
Of the ones I have read - which is all the rest - I say a big YEP to.

Phyl said...

I still have Breathless on my TBR pile. Why is that? Bad Phyl! And I read the Firebrand trilogy thanks to your recommendation. I loved all 3 books. You have quite a few in your list I've never read, but I do gravitate toward British historicals. Anyhow, my list is up too, without the commentary, cuz I'm lazy!

Mollie said...

GUH! These top 16 posts are KILLING me! As if my TBR pile wasn't toppling over already!!!!!

lustyreader said...

oh i can't believe my top 16 list doesn't have ANY in common with yours! but your Westerns bandwagon is always just a little too far away from my Regency one ;) I still have my list from the Great Western Drive and now have more to add to it, great post!

Leslie said...

Agree about Megan Hart - romance, just not your standard romance. Love her stories.

Adding Eschenburg to my list - never heard of her but it sounds good. And the library actually has the Sutcliffe so I'll be getting that one. Great list Wendy!

nath said...

Great list!! Many I still haven't read or heard of ^_^;

Evangeline Holland said...

Oh crap! How could I have forgotten To Dream Again on my list? It's why I keep trying LLG's books, hoping she will live up to this awesome, awesome book again. :/

Anonymous said...

If I were to list another tomorrow, mine would be similar to yours.

I'd list Guhrke's Breathless/To Dream Away; Morsi's CMC (I chose Runabout for mine); Lee's Gossamer (agreed with your comments); a Maggie Osborne (I should have listed her category rom - under her other name Margaret St. George - Love Bites) and Cheryl Reavis's The Long Way Home (I thought about listing one of her Bride books and eventually threw her over for Spencer's November of the Heart). :D

Susan Wiggs's The Firebrand is a good one. I think I liked the other Great Fire of Chicago book more. The one with the matchstick factory?

Never heard of Megan Hart and her book, so will give this one a try. Thank you!

Maili x

Karen W. said...

We have VERY similar taste, Wendy. Especially our love for American/western historicals! Great list.

Rowena said...

Holy goodness Wendy, I haven't read ANY of the books on your list. I don't even own any of them, I must fix this!

Katie Mack said...

Wow. You're pretty serious about your American Historical love, aren't you. ;)

I loved I Do, I Do, I Do by Maggie Osborne. It's also the only book on your list I've read. But I'm adding Bad Moon Rising to my TBR pile stat (we'll see how long it takes me to actually read it), and probably the Megan Hart too.

Wendy said...

Kristie: You really need to read those Rock Creek Six books! I've done my part. I've read Dreaming Of You, Ride the Fire, and both Judith James novels. Frankly, you owe me :)

Phyl: Ooooh, you need to read Breathless! Fantastic, super-duper librarian heroine. I mean - she's just awesome.

Mollie: These lists tend to be brutal for everybody.

Lusty & Everybody Else Who Mentioned It: This list is quite heavy on American historicals (not just the westerns) because my English historical burn out was so bad for a few years. I literally could not bring myself to read them. At all. I just started getting back into them thanks to short stories - but I was a strict starvation diet for about 3 years there.....

Leslie: Eschenburg only published two books, then dropped off the map. I'm hoping she's still OK, and that the breast cancer didn't come back on her....

Nath: You're bigger into contemporaries than I am - that's probably why :)

Evangeline: Wasn't that an awesome book? I was sort of nervous when I read it, because I love Breathless so much - but honestly, I had nothing to worry about. The emotional intensity in that story took my breath away.

Maili: I know! How do you pick one Morsi and one Osborne? You almost have to flip a coin.

Karen: They're my favorites!

Rowena: I just tend to naturally gravitate towards the American historicals.....

Katie: I loved Bad Moon Rising. Loved it! I need to do a reread to make sure it holds up. Part of the reason I loved it so much was how "shocking" it was at the time it was published. It was really dark, and hello? A heroine who used to be a prostitute? You should have seen the message boards at the time. Some readers completely lost their sh*t just thinking about the possibility....

~ames~ said...

Interesting list Wendy. I think I've read one! LOL

I'm going to look out for Breathless and Courting Miss Hattie. Those sound delicious.

Carolyn Crane said...

Oh, wow! Great list. So many I don't know.

I just pasted your entire description of Breathless to my TBB list. Wow. I love books about librarians.

Jill D. said...

Wendy - Bad Moon Rising, Courting Miss Hattie and Dirty all just missed my list. I love all those books and I know at least two of them I read based on your recommendations.

This was such a fun idea. I am so glad you participated!

Kate said...

Oh my god. I've never read a thing on your list, nor have I heard of most of the authors. Shame! Fie! List of things to do...

Jessica said...

This is so great! Thank you for participating! Your list is like Maili's -- I don;t know many of these books at all, which is terrific, because I now have many many new ideas.

And Dirty has appeared on so many lists -- I wonder if Megan Hart knows she wrote a classic?

Wendy said...

Ames: Breathless and Courting Miss Hattie ARE delicious :)

Carolyn: Best librarian ever. Says me.

Jill: Probably Courting Miss Hattie and Dirty. I don't think I've ever really blogged about Bad Moon Rising. I really need to reread that one.....

Kate: I'm determined to drag readers (kicking and screaming if need be) over to the dark side of American historicals. Heh.

Jessica: I went with Dirty because it was Hart's debut for Spice, and it literally knocked the wind right out of me. I loved Broken just as much, but Dirty edges it out just because that was how I "discovered" her.

Kate Diamond said...

Interesting! I haven't read ANY of the books on your list, although I've read books by almost all of the authors. Hm... looks like the TBR pile has some growing to do...